There is no single rejection rate
Here, rejection means deciding not to use a prosthesis, not an immune reaction. Studies variously measure rejection of one device, discontinuation of all prostheses, or non-use at a survey date. Occasional, task-specific use is different again. Those outcomes should not be pooled into one industry-wide failure rate.
- Adult upper limbs: 26% and 23%. Biddiss and Chau’s 2007 review reported mean rejection rates for body-powered and electric devices, respectively. Its search ended in February 2006; 40 papers supplied rejection rates. These heterogeneous historical averages are not estimates for today’s devices, or a fair head-to-head ranking. [1]
- A different upper-limb sample: 9%. Yamamoto and colleagues reported 16 non-users among 174 respondents in 2019. Only 47% of the 367 people invited responded, and the four centres offered intensive rehabilitation. Selection and non-response limit generalisation; the lower figure does not prove that technology reduced rejection. [2]
- Lower limbs: 11–22% at approximately one year. A 2018 AHRQ review found low-strength evidence that this proportion of prescribed recipients stopped using their prosthesis. The underlying studies were mostly old. This is historical context, not a current UK rate, and should remain separate from upper-limb findings. [3]
Why a capable device can remain unused
Smail and colleagues’ scoping review identified recurring upper-limb concerns around weight, heat, perspiration, control and missing sensory feedback. Some participants found themselves more functional without their device. The review included only nine studies and highlighted limited evidence on contemporary technology. [4]
Lower-limb use also depends on health, mobility and rehabilitation. A 2024 review of 29 studies, representing 4,814 participants, examined factors including amputation level, comorbidities, skin condition and social support. Device design is one part of that pathway. [5] Non-use should prompt investigation, not an assumption that the person failed to adapt.
The industry cost of unused capability
Our interpretation is that abandonment changes the commercial question: a delivered device is not evidence of sustained benefit. Fitting, training, repairs and replacement all belong in the value proposition. These studies do not establish a defensible industry-wide financial loss from abandonment.
A Dutch economic evaluation of 242 upper-limb prosthesis users found higher costs for multi-grip than standard myoelectric hands, without significant differences in the measured quality-of-life and user-experience scores across device types. This challenges automatic assumptions about premium technology. It was a survey-based comparison, not a randomised trial; some costs were estimated, and non-users were excluded. It cannot measure the cost of abandonment, and individual users may still benefit from multi-grip devices. [6]
What this means for Touch
For Touch, our proposed development priority is useful control that people choose to use. Additional joints, AI assistance or sensory feedback should demonstrate enough benefit to justify their weight, complexity and training demands.
We would involve current users and people who stopped using prostheses, then evaluate meaningful tasks, comfort, control effort, repair downtime and continued use at defined follow-up points. Reasons for stopping matter as much as the rate. Success can include selective use—or an informed choice to use no prosthesis. Touch remains a research programme; reduced abandonment has not been demonstrated.
Sources
- Biddiss & Chau (2007). Upper limb prosthesis use and abandonment: a survey of the last 25 years. Prosthetics and Orthotics International. Historical literature review.
- Yamamoto et al. (2019). Multicentre study of quality of life and upper-limb prosthesis abandonment. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery – Global Open. Cross-sectional survey.
- Balk et al. (2018). Lower Limb Prostheses: evidence summary. AHRQ Comparative Effectiveness Review 213. Archived systematic review; not a current prevalence estimate.
- Smail et al. (2021; online 2020). Comfort, function and upper-limb prosthetic abandonment. Disability and Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology. Scoping review.
- Paquette et al. (2024; online 2023). Duration, frequency and factors related to lower-extremity prosthesis use. Disability and Rehabilitation. Systematic review and meta-analysis.
- Kerver et al. (2023; online 2022). Economic evaluation of upper-limb prostheses in the Netherlands. Disability and Rehabilitation. Survey-based economic evaluation.
